Alle Meldungen
Rallyman: GT Meldungen
#119923: "End Game statistics are incorrect and misleading."
#119923: "End Game statistics are incorrect and misleading."
open: Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen
119923
Worum geht es bei dieser Meldung?
Was ist passiert? Bitte wähle unten aus
Anzeigefehler: Irgendeine Information zum Spiel wurde falsch angezeigt (ohne starke Beeinträchtigung des Spiels)
Was ist passiert? Bitte wähle unten aus
Anzeigefehler: Irgendeine Information zum Spiel wurde falsch angezeigt (ohne starke Beeinträchtigung des Spiels)
Bitte überprüfe, ob bereits eine Meldung zum gleichen Thema existiert
Wenn ja, STIMME bitte für diese Meldung. Meldungen mit mehr Stimmen erhalten höhere PRIORITÄT!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Detaillierte Beschreibung
• Falls du eine Fehlermeldung auf dem Bildschirm siehst, bitte kopieren und einfügen.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Bitte erkläre, was du machen wolltest, was du dann getan hast und was dann passiert ist
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Bitte kopiere den Text, der in Englisch anstatt in deiner Sprache angezeigt wird, und füge ihn hier ein. Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Ist dieser Text auf der Übersetzungsseite verfügbar? Wenn ja, wurde dieser vor mehr als 24 Stunden übersetzt?
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Bitte erkläre deinen Vorschlag so präzise und genau wie möglich, damit er leicht zu verstehen ist.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Was wurde auf dem Bildschirm angezeigt, als du blockiert wurdest (weißer Bildschirm? Teil der Spieloberfläche? Fehlermeldung?)
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Welcher Teil der Spielregel wurde durch die BGA-Adaption nicht beachtet?
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Ist der Regelverstoß in der Spielwiederholung zu sehen? Falls ja, bei welcher Zugnummer?
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Welche Spielaktion wolltest du durchführen?
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Was versuchst du, um diese Spielaktion auszulösen?
• Was passiert, wenn du dies versuchst (Fehlermeldung, Statusmeldung des Spiels, ...)?
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• An welcher Stelle im Spiel ist das Problem aufgetreten? Was war die aktuelle Spielanweisung?
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Was passiert, wenn du die Spielaktion ausführen möchtest (Fehlermeldung, Statusmeldung des Spiels, ...)?
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Bitte beschreibe die Anzeigeschwierigkeiten. Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Bitte kopiere den Text, der in Englisch anstatt in deiner Sprache angezeigt wird, und füge ihn hier ein. Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Ist dieser Text auf der Übersetzungsseite verfügbar? Wenn ja, wurde dieser vor mehr als 24 Stunden übersetzt?
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
• Bitte erkläre deinen Vorschlag so präzise und genau wie möglich, damit er leicht zu verstehen ist.
The end of game statistics are wrong, and misleading.
I carefully tracked one such game - this table.
At the end of the race, My tracking should:
The game reports these values:
imgur.com/76JG4xg
# of 1! dice rolled: 49
# of 1! dice failed: 8
# of 2! dice rolled: 29
# of 2! dice failed: 10
However, I tracked my rolls very carefully, and triple checked the results compared to the game log:
the values should be:
# of 1! dice rolled: 44
# of 1! dice failed: 9
# of 2! dice rolled: 26
# of 2! dice failed: 11
It seems it counts the dice that are "secured" as being rolled - which is misleading for statistics.
It also isn't counting the failures correctly, Seems it's reducing the # of failures by 1 for some reason.
The game reports :
1! % thrown: 16.3265%
2! % thrown: 34.4828%
which is pretty close to expected values .. however, in reality, this particular game should be:
1! % thrown: 20.45%
2! % thrown: 42.31%
I felt it was throwing a lot of "!", and the end game stats were confusing me, so I dug a bit deeper.
• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
Meldungshistorie
5. Apr 2024 2:32 • Ditto11 • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
Here's my turn by turn breakdown:
Turn 1: 12www3 (!: 2 )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5
# of 1! dice failed: 1 (the 2nd gear failed)
# of 2! dice rolled: 1
# of 2! dice failed: 0
Turn 2: 1r23w4ww (!: rw )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 10 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 2 ) (one white die failed)
# of 2! dice rolled: 3 ( 4 )
# of 2! dice failed: 1 ( 1 ) (one red die failed)
Turn 3: 1rrw (!: rrw )
# of 1! dice rolled: 2 ( 12 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 3 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 6 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 3 )
Turn 4: 123ww4w (!: 13w4 )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 17 )
# of 1! dice failed: 2 ( 5 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 8 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 5 )
Turn 5: 234rr1www (!: 3r )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 22 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 5 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 4 ( 12 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 7 )
Turn 6: 1www234 (!: w )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 27 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 6 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 14 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
Turn 7: 1rr234ww (!: 34 ) (Sec: w)
# of 1! dice rolled: 3 ( 30 ) *Rolled: 12w (the 2nd w was secured; not rolled)
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 16 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 9 )
Turn 8: 4321www (!: - )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 35 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 18 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 9: 2w341rrww (!: - )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 40 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 4 ( 22 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 10: 1234w (!: 1w )
# of 1! dice rolled: 3 ( 43 )
# of 1! dice failed: 2 ( 9 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 24 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 11: 1rr234www (!: 34 ) (Sec: 1rrwww)
# of 1! dice rolled: 1 ( 44 ) *Rolled: 2nd gear die only. others were secured.
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 26 ) *Rolled: 3 and 4 - two red were secured.
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 11 )
Here's google sheet to help track/count the values if you're interested in checking yourself.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LrW3U0X2MlTlkQHx2gGdq4MAb3AKtpNWCGDBqvLYllc/edit?usp=sharing
Turn 1: 12www3 (!: 2 )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5
# of 1! dice failed: 1 (the 2nd gear failed)
# of 2! dice rolled: 1
# of 2! dice failed: 0
Turn 2: 1r23w4ww (!: rw )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 10 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 2 ) (one white die failed)
# of 2! dice rolled: 3 ( 4 )
# of 2! dice failed: 1 ( 1 ) (one red die failed)
Turn 3: 1rrw (!: rrw )
# of 1! dice rolled: 2 ( 12 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 3 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 6 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 3 )
Turn 4: 123ww4w (!: 13w4 )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 17 )
# of 1! dice failed: 2 ( 5 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 8 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 5 )
Turn 5: 234rr1www (!: 3r )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 22 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 5 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 4 ( 12 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 7 )
Turn 6: 1www234 (!: w )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 27 )
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 6 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 14 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
Turn 7: 1rr234ww (!: 34 ) (Sec: w)
# of 1! dice rolled: 3 ( 30 ) *Rolled: 12w (the 2nd w was secured; not rolled)
# of 1! dice failed: 1 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 16 )
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 9 )
Turn 8: 4321www (!: - )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 35 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 18 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 9: 2w341rrww (!: - )
# of 1! dice rolled: 5 ( 40 )
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 7 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 4 ( 22 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 10: 1234w (!: 1w )
# of 1! dice rolled: 3 ( 43 )
# of 1! dice failed: 2 ( 9 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 24 )
# of 2! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
Turn 11: 1rr234www (!: 34 ) (Sec: 1rrwww)
# of 1! dice rolled: 1 ( 44 ) *Rolled: 2nd gear die only. others were secured.
# of 1! dice failed: 0 ( 9 )
# of 2! dice rolled: 2 ( 26 ) *Rolled: 3 and 4 - two red were secured.
# of 2! dice failed: 2 ( 11 )
Here's google sheet to help track/count the values if you're interested in checking yourself.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LrW3U0X2MlTlkQHx2gGdq4MAb3AKtpNWCGDBqvLYllc/edit?usp=sharing
5. Apr 2024 3:13 • Ditto11 • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
Another example:
Table: 495925712
Norisring map, GT6.
I played simple and very safe, generated lightning bolts, and used those to secure as many rolls as I could.
It's clear the game is counting secured dice as "rolled" .. and that will skew statistics greatly ..
The shared google sheet in previous also has a tab for this game.
in game stats reports 23 1! dice rolled, but I secured two 1's. so should only be 21 rolled.
It also reports 16 2!, but should be 11, as I secured a 5,6 and 3x Red dice along the way.
As a result of this, the in game statistics are VERY generous .. reporting much lower %'s of "!" thrown than what is actually happening.
Very misleading.
Table: 495925712
Norisring map, GT6.
I played simple and very safe, generated lightning bolts, and used those to secure as many rolls as I could.
It's clear the game is counting secured dice as "rolled" .. and that will skew statistics greatly ..
The shared google sheet in previous also has a tab for this game.
in game stats reports 23 1! dice rolled, but I secured two 1's. so should only be 21 rolled.
It also reports 16 2!, but should be 11, as I secured a 5,6 and 3x Red dice along the way.
As a result of this, the in game statistics are VERY generous .. reporting much lower %'s of "!" thrown than what is actually happening.
Very misleading.
Ergänze diese Meldung
Bitte erwähne hier alles, was bedeutsam sein könnte, um diesen Fehler nachzuvollziehen oder deinen Vorschlag zu verstehen:
- Eine andere Tisch ID / Zug ID
- Konnte F5 das Problem lösen?
- Trat das Problem öfter auf? Jedes Mal? Zufällig?
- Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
Ändere den Status der Meldung auf:
bug?id=119923
