Alle Meldungen
Umbrella Meldungen
#163015: "Unable to create a tutorial due to missing ID attributes in the HTML"
implemented: Dieser Vorschlag wurde umgesetzt
1
Worum geht es bei dieser Meldung?
Was ist passiert? Bitte wähle unten aus
Vorschlag: meiner Meinung nach würde das Folgende die Umsetzung des Spiels erheblich verbessern
Detaillierte Beschreibung
• Bitte erkläre deinen Vorschlag so präzise und genau wie möglich, damit er leicht zu verstehen ist.
Please, add ID to all elements in the game to make it compatible with BGA tutorial creator, and check for overlapping DIVs. This BGA page explains this in more detail: en.doc.boardgamearena.com/Tutorials_checklist
Specifically:
"If a player trying to create a tutorial reports you an issue about (3):
- you might have some overlapping elements preventing to access the "div" tag of an important interface element to attach tutorial content to it.
- you might have some missing "ID" on elements of the interface, preventing the tutorial author to attach elements to them."• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v134
Meldungshistorie
30. Mär 2025 9:34 • Infi220 • Dieser Vorschlag wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht untersucht:
I think the problem is that these divs don't have an ID:
<div class="um_umbrella bg-umbrella_2" style="position: relative;">
I did an experiment with Chrome dev tools, and when I manually add an ID to this div, then the tutorial works.
<div class="um_umbrella bg-umbrella_2" style="position: relative;">
I did an experiment with Chrome dev tools, and when I manually add an ID to this div, then the tutorial works.
30. Mär 2025 9:52 • Moof • Die Entwickler hätten gern mehr Informationen zu diesem Vorschlag:
Can you try again please?
30. Mär 2025 19:01 • Infi220 • Die Entwickler hätten gern mehr Informationen zu diesem Vorschlag:
It works better now but not completely. The ID fix allows me to mark the elements in the tutorial, but it's still impossible to click them and take an action in the replay. You can see my tutorial test here:
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/250326-1050/?table=651495995&player=97510471&comments=88656919;
BGA explains the likely cause on this page: en.doc.boardgamearena.com/Tutorials_checklist
[Quote]
Each action of the replay should be replayable by triggering it manually (i.e. by reproducing the exact same sequence as done played originally during the game
(...) most likely reasons for the issue are:
- that you have triggered this.ajaxcall() / this.bgaPerformAction() programmatically in a notification handling function or a callback instead of only on a user interface action.
- or that there are several way to trigger the next action with different URL/arguments. You should make sure that the same game actions are triggered with the same "ajaxcall" / "bgaPerformAction" whatever the UX path used.
[/Quote]
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/250326-1050/?table=651495995&player=97510471&comments=88656919;
BGA explains the likely cause on this page: en.doc.boardgamearena.com/Tutorials_checklist
[Quote]
Each action of the replay should be replayable by triggering it manually (i.e. by reproducing the exact same sequence as done played originally during the game
(...) most likely reasons for the issue are:
- that you have triggered this.ajaxcall() / this.bgaPerformAction() programmatically in a notification handling function or a callback instead of only on a user interface action.
- or that there are several way to trigger the next action with different URL/arguments. You should make sure that the same game actions are triggered with the same "ajaxcall" / "bgaPerformAction" whatever the UX path used.
[/Quote]
30. Mär 2025 19:48 • Moof • Die Entwickler hätten gern mehr Informationen zu diesem Vorschlag:
I pushed a modification but I can't access your replay, can u check please?
1. Apr 2025 4:35 • Infi220 • Die Entwickler hätten gern mehr Informationen zu diesem Vorschlag:
I tried again and the problem. So, I looked into the code again and found the issue. There is an if() condition in the following 3 functions in UmBoard.js:
activateCards
activatePoints
activateUmbrellas
That if() looks like this:
if (this.root.isReadOnly()) return;
Since isReadOnly() returns true in a replay, it causes those 3 functions to quit prematurely.
Removing all 3 occurrences of that if() fixes the replay.
activateCards
activatePoints
activateUmbrellas
That if() looks like this:
if (this.root.isReadOnly()) return;
Since isReadOnly() returns true in a replay, it causes those 3 functions to quit prematurely.
Removing all 3 occurrences of that if() fixes the replay.
1. Apr 2025 17:33 • Infi220 • Dieser Vorschlag wurde umgesetzt:
Thank you! That issue has been fixed now. There is just one last thing: could you please add IDs to the arrow DIVs that show on the player board after selecting an umbrella? Those DIVs look like this:
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_1"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_2"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_3"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_4"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_1"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_2"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_3"></div>
<div class="um_arrow bg-arrow_4"></div>
2. Apr 2025 9:10 • Moof • Dieser Vorschlag wurde umgesetzt:
Done.
Note that those div were already encapsulated in other div with id, like I usually do. But now you have both id
Note that those div were already encapsulated in other div with id, like I usually do. But now you have both id
3. Apr 2025 8:01 • Infi220 • Dieser Vorschlag wurde umgesetzt:
I tried it just now and those inner divs still don't have an ID. Screenshot: snipboard.io/VtOX74.jpg
I'm aware the outer divs have IDs but the BGA tutorial interface needs the inner divs with IDs too. If it's not much trouble could you please check why your last fix wasn't applied?
I can do a workaround but it won't be as nice as if the IDs were there.
I'm aware the outer divs have IDs but the BGA tutorial interface needs the inner divs with IDs too. If it's not much trouble could you please check why your last fix wasn't applied?
I can do a workaround but it won't be as nice as if the IDs were there.
3. Apr 2025 8:08 • Moof • Dieser Vorschlag wurde umgesetzt:
The patch wasnt in production. This should be ok now.
Ergänze diese Meldung
Bitte erwähne hier alles, was bedeutsam sein könnte, um diesen Fehler nachzuvollziehen oder deinen Vorschlag zu verstehen:
- Eine weitere Tisch-ID/Zug-ID
- Konnte F5 das Problem lösen?
- Trat das Problem öfter auf? Jedes Mal? Zufällig?
- Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
