Alle Meldungen
Rallyman: DIRT Meldungen
#123652: "LOC using coast on jump, forced to place all dice."
infoneeded: Die Entwickler brauchen mehr Informationen, um den Fehler nachzuvollziehen
Worum geht es bei dieser Meldung?
Was ist passiert? Bitte wähle unten aus
Regeln: Eine Regel des Spiels wurde nicht beachtet
Detaillierte Beschreibung
• Welcher Teil der Spielregel wurde durch die BGA-Adaption nicht beachtet?
I went flat out over a 4 jump with 5 coast and rolled a /!\ on that specific die (hard to tell though). I only rolled 2 /!\ , so I had to place as I originally did. The bug was that it made me place ALL of my dice, including the gear 6 after my LOC occurred on the 5 coast. This resulted in me drawing an additional damage for ending in gear 6 instead of gear 5, and being 1 space closer to the finish line (lowers my time next turn at finish).
I should stop placing dice after the LOC occurs.• Ist der Regelverstoß in der Spielwiederholung zu sehen? Falls ja, bei welcher Zugnummer?
621• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v123
Meldungshistorie
11. Mai 2024 18:57 • Magnus3740 • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
13. Jun 2024 22:01 • FrankCavil • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
Another example on boardgamearena.com/13/rallymandirt?table=524900610&replayFrom=131
18. Jun 2024 14:24 • FrankCavil • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
And another, but this time as an image: imgur.com/cD6DcgX
7. Jul 2024 18:40 • FrankCavil • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
And a better example on the same jump: imgur.com/2JmHOxW
boardgamearena.com/11/rallymandirt?table=534431617&replayFrom=639
Only 2 hazards are recorded on the dice, meaning my LoC had to have occured going over the jump in too high a gear (as the log correctly shows), but I can lay out my dice to go over the jump safely and once all have been placed, I then get the option to resolve the LoC.
Resolving the loss of control should be as a result of actually losing control, be it through speeding in the corner or over the jump, not as a result of defaulting to 'the turn must have ended with a LoC, therefore LoC', if that makes any sense.
boardgamearena.com/11/rallymandirt?table=534431617&replayFrom=639
Only 2 hazards are recorded on the dice, meaning my LoC had to have occured going over the jump in too high a gear (as the log correctly shows), but I can lay out my dice to go over the jump safely and once all have been placed, I then get the option to resolve the LoC.
Resolving the loss of control should be as a result of actually losing control, be it through speeding in the corner or over the jump, not as a result of defaulting to 'the turn must have ended with a LoC, therefore LoC', if that makes any sense.
7. Jul 2024 19:03 • ODaly • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
Yes JC has clarified this a couple different times. Players are not forced to remember which coast dice goes where after they re-allocate after a Flat Out roll. If changing the order of the coast dice would avoid the LoC, then the player ends their turn safely.
10. Jul 2024 21:51 • zombiegod • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
boardgamearena.com/4/rallymandirt?table=535740697&replayFrom=151
LoC with a Brake! a 3! and a 4!.
However, even though I was near a jump 3 and a jump 4 space. I was forced to use all 3 hazards rolled. I believe in practice I should be allowed to rearrange and LOC over either of the jumps.
tinyurl.com/2s37bw4k
tinyurl.com/4tdftrh7
LoC with a Brake! a 3! and a 4!.
However, even though I was near a jump 3 and a jump 4 space. I was forced to use all 3 hazards rolled. I believe in practice I should be allowed to rearrange and LOC over either of the jumps.
tinyurl.com/2s37bw4k
tinyurl.com/4tdftrh7
16. Sep 2024 14:13 • Diana Sianodel • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
Hi,
Same problem herer
boardgamearena.com/14/rallymandirt?table=559899092&replayFrom=1496
1st roll of stage 4.
Same problem herer
boardgamearena.com/14/rallymandirt?table=559899092&replayFrom=1496
1st roll of stage 4.
5. Dez 2024 20:27 • frafa • Der Fehler wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht nachvollzogen:
It happened to me twice.
Last occurence here, around step #90
boardgamearena.com/table?table=598023357
Jumped speed 4 on bump 3. Got a warn. Had to place all my dice anyway and got the damages of gear 6 (instead of 4)!!
Last occurence here, around step #90
boardgamearena.com/table?table=598023357
Jumped speed 4 on bump 3. Got a warn. Had to place all my dice anyway and got the damages of gear 6 (instead of 4)!!
11. Dez 2024 10:41 • derby-digital • Die Entwickler brauchen mehr Informationen, um den Fehler nachzuvollziehen:
Hello, if I understand correctly, we have to remove the warnings from the coast and leader dice after a LOC?
11. Dez 2024 15:05 • Magnus3740 • Die Entwickler brauchen mehr Informationen, um den Fehler nachzuvollziehen:
No, the issue was the game did not recognize HOW we should be placing the dice after an LOC from jumping. If the die rolled is one gear higher than the jump AND that die rolls /!\ (but only rolling individually, not flat out) it will cause a Loss of Control. However, all the game sees is that a LOC happened, so place all the dice until you place 3 warnings. In this case only two warnings were rolled, so the game had me place all dice, then said I had a LOC.
JCB mentioned an exception to the dice rolling over a jump. If a coast die is used (and the gear is higher) and BOTH coast die are used that turn AND only one rolls a warning, then you don't know which it is for. Maybe talk with him and the publisher if you want to program that exception.
JCB mentioned an exception to the dice rolling over a jump. If a coast die is used (and the gear is higher) and BOTH coast die are used that turn AND only one rolls a warning, then you don't know which it is for. Maybe talk with him and the publisher if you want to program that exception.
11. Dez 2024 17:04 • Magnus3740 • Die Entwickler brauchen mehr Informationen, um den Fehler nachzuvollziehen:
I was able to recreate it on table 600485337 move 76
Rally 6 SS2, tile 205b
I place 4, 5, L (jump 4), L, 6 (after finish line). I rolled a 4, 5, L!, L, 6 flat out, which caused a LOC due to rolling a Leader ! (5) on a jump 4. The rule book says this immediately causes a Loss of Control, but ONLY when rolling dice individually. JCB clarified that in a flat out roll it would not cause a LOC. So, according to designer, this is not a Loss of Control.
imgur.com/gallery/ouioxey
HOWEVER, if the publisher says this is a loss of control, then there is another bug.
I placed my dice in the same order to cause the original LOC. The game did not recognize this as a LOC and did not let me end my turn. (BUG)
It did let me play all my dice two different ways
1 - jump at speed 4 and no LOC is caused (yet it resolves as a LOC)
2 - place all my dice as originally done. Instead of the IMMEDIATE LOC at the space (L5!) and giving me 1 minute for turn time, the LOC was resolved after the finish line and my turn time was 10 seconds.
I hope this makes things clearer.
Rally 6 SS2, tile 205b
I place 4, 5, L (jump 4), L, 6 (after finish line). I rolled a 4, 5, L!, L, 6 flat out, which caused a LOC due to rolling a Leader ! (5) on a jump 4. The rule book says this immediately causes a Loss of Control, but ONLY when rolling dice individually. JCB clarified that in a flat out roll it would not cause a LOC. So, according to designer, this is not a Loss of Control.
imgur.com/gallery/ouioxey
HOWEVER, if the publisher says this is a loss of control, then there is another bug.
I placed my dice in the same order to cause the original LOC. The game did not recognize this as a LOC and did not let me end my turn. (BUG)
It did let me play all my dice two different ways
1 - jump at speed 4 and no LOC is caused (yet it resolves as a LOC)
2 - place all my dice as originally done. Instead of the IMMEDIATE LOC at the space (L5!) and giving me 1 minute for turn time, the LOC was resolved after the finish line and my turn time was 10 seconds.
I hope this makes things clearer.
3. Jan 2025 7:15 • ODaly • Die Entwickler brauchen mehr Informationen, um den Fehler nachzuvollziehen:
The main problem with jumps is that the game checks for LoC when you roll the dice, instead of checking at the time the car actually travels over the jump. Adjust when the LoC check is made, and this issue gets resolved.
Ergänze diese Meldung
Bitte erwähne hier alles, was bedeutsam sein könnte, um diesen Fehler nachzuvollziehen oder deinen Vorschlag zu verstehen:
- Eine weitere Tisch-ID/Zug-ID
- Konnte F5 das Problem lösen?
- Trat das Problem öfter auf? Jedes Mal? Zufällig?
- Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
