Alle Meldungen
Maracaibo Meldungen
#105636: "Undo for end of round action?"
rejected: Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist
1
Worum geht es bei dieser Meldung?
Was ist passiert? Bitte wähle unten aus
Vorschlag: meiner Meinung nach würde das Folgende die Umsetzung des Spiels erheblich verbessern
Detaillierte Beschreibung
• Bitte erkläre deinen Vorschlag so präzise und genau wie möglich, damit er leicht zu verstehen ist.
Would be nice to have an undo after buying the card, before locking in the action and waiting for other players• Welchen Browser benutzt du?
Google Chrome v119
Meldungshistorie
30. Nov 2023 23:38 • n1caboose • Dieser Vorschlag wurde von den Entwicklern noch nicht untersucht:
.
30. Nov 2023 23:45 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
The end of round card play automatically ends your turn and prompts the next player, so we can't undo during someone else's turn. We can add a confirmation, though that starts requiring more clicks for players. Let us know if you'd like to do that.
1. Dez 2023 4:30 • n1caboose • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
Confirmation would be good to have I think. Would that then allow for an Undo button to appear before this Confirmation is pressed?
1. Dez 2023 4:44 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
No, it would be an "are you sure?" button that appears when you try to buy a card. So you'd click either "gain 2VP" or "buy card" and then you'd choose the card and click "confirm" (I believe this is the current sequence; I'm sure the button names are better), then you'd add an extra click that reads "yes, really confirm" with better wording.
Buying a card is an atomic action that constitutes your entire turn at this point, so once you've confirmed the card your turn automatically ends and a player's turn begins. At that point, undo doesn't work because it interferes with the new player's turn.
Buying a card is an atomic action that constitutes your entire turn at this point, so once you've confirmed the card your turn automatically ends and a player's turn begins. At that point, undo doesn't work because it interferes with the new player's turn.
18. Jan 2024 23:39 • Nasher1976 • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
It's actually not buying the card I want to undo, it's the effect of the card which is to remove a token from my ship.
18. Jan 2024 23:53 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
Once you perform that effect, it is no longer your turn. At that point, undo doesn't work because it interferes with the new player's turn.
19. Jan 2024 0:35 • Nasher1976 • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
It is still my turn, it's asking me to draw cards, therefore an undo should be available. The reason why this is important also is because it didn't ask me what influence marker to move up, it just gave me one option (perhaps another bug?)
19. Jan 2024 0:38 • Nasher1976 • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
19. Jan 2024 2:03 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
The amount of effort required to add an undo for this narrow case isn't justified. You can certainly undo your turn when you're taking it, but for the single decision (play a card or gain 2VP) at round's end, we won't be adding undo.
19. Jan 2024 8:49 • Nasher1976 • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
It's not a narrow case, it's whenever you buy a card.
19. Jan 2024 14:24 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
The amount of effort required to add an undo for this single decision isn't justified. You can certainly undo your turn when you're taking it, but for the single decision (play a card or gain 2VP) at round's end, we won't be adding undo.
19. Jan 2024 14:33 • Nasher1976 • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
This isn't about buying a card a round's end.
19. Jan 2024 15:53 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
Suggestion title: "Undo for end of round action?"
Suggestion text: "Would be nice to have an undo after buying the card"
> This isn't about buying a card a round's end.
This suggestion is about adding an undo to buying a card at the end of the round. It's been asked and answered, repeatedly.
When you give a single-line response to say that someone is wrong without explaining what you believe is right, it's simply argumentative. You're welcome to take such debates to the forums, but further argumentative responses will be removed from suggestions/bugs.
Suggestion text: "Would be nice to have an undo after buying the card"
> This isn't about buying a card a round's end.
This suggestion is about adding an undo to buying a card at the end of the round. It's been asked and answered, repeatedly.
When you give a single-line response to say that someone is wrong without explaining what you believe is right, it's simply argumentative. You're welcome to take such debates to the forums, but further argumentative responses will be removed from suggestions/bugs.
22. Mär 2025 14:40 • DarthCthulhu • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
I agree this is a problem. There's no reason I shouldn't be able to undo the card I buy at the end of round. It's not the next players turn yet as I still haven't drawn a card. If I were playing with people in person, I could just say "oops never mind,I want to play this instead".
It's not that outlandish of a concept imo
It's not that outlandish of a concept imo
22. Mär 2025 14:58 • Kayvon • Die Entwickler denken, dass es keine gute Idee ist, oder dass das Verhältnis von Aufwand zu Nutzen zu hoch ist:
I agree, it's not outlandish. If it were as simple as checking a box, I would do it. The amount of effort required to add an undo for this narrow case isn't justified. You can certainly undo your turn when you're taking it, but for the single decision (play a card or gain 2VP) at round's end, we won't be adding undo.
Ergänze diese Meldung
Bitte erwähne hier alles, was bedeutsam sein könnte, um diesen Fehler nachzuvollziehen oder deinen Vorschlag zu verstehen:
- Eine weitere Tisch-ID/Zug-ID
- Konnte F5 das Problem lösen?
- Trat das Problem öfter auf? Jedes Mal? Zufällig?
- Falls du einen Screenshot dieses Fehlers hast (optimale Vorgehensweise), kannst du ihn bei Imgur.com hochladen, den Link kopieren und hier einfügen.
